Good Day,
I was reading a recent news article about housing prices and being based in South Florida of course I was pleased to see that one of our local communities showed a 15% gain in values from 2008 to August 2011. This is great news for sellers and of course for those buyers looking for a “bottom” in prices, its apparant that at least in this community, the bottom has come and gone. Other recent data shows that foreclosure and other distressed sales as a percentage of all sales have dropped considerably from their 2008 peak.
With interest rates still at historic lows, and prices on a slight incline, for those buyers sitting on the fence, its probably a pretty good time to consider making the jump to be a homeowner. But of course credit markets have changed… and the media is full of news that its so much harder to get a loan these days… So what IS required to get a home loan today?
Actually to dispell the myths perpuated by the mainstream media, while its more work to go through the process, most qualified buyers can get a new home loan. It really is back to basics for the mortgage loan application proces and this is the focus on this article.
What do lenders look at? Theses are known as the basic tenets of lending also known as the 5C’s of Credit:
- Character – (Credit)
- Cash – (Equity)
- Collateral – (The home value and condition)
- Capacity – (The ability to repay the loan – AKA Income)
- Compensating Factors – (for loans that push some guidelines, something that offsets that risk)
Lets look at each and what you must do to get ready to talk to a lender. As always, if you have any questions, please call us or write at Mason@PrunerMortgage.com.
First lets look at Character. This is the Willingness to repay the loan as demonstrated by the your credit history. Years ago it was a simple review of the history, but in the last 20 years, credit scores – also known as “FICO” scores (Named for the Fair Issac Corporation who devised the first score model) have played an increasing role in the decision with minimum scores required for different kinds of loans. Normally you are looking at 600 for FHA loans and a minimum of 620 for conventional loans with substantial rate adjustments for lower scores. If your score is lower, you will end up paying more for the home mortgage loan via higher rates and/or fees.
Your score is made up from the following criteria as reported in your credit profile:
- 35%: Payment history—Late payments on bills, such as a mortgage, credit card or automobile loan, can cause a credit score to drop. Bills paid on time will improve a credit score. Any late payments in the last 12 months have a more significant impact on score.
- 30%: Credit utilization—The ratio of current revolving debt (such as credit card balances) to the total available credit limit. credit scores can be improved by paying down debt and lowering the credit utilization ratio. Alternatively, credit limit increases can also drive down the utilization ratio. The closing of existing revolving accounts will typically adversely affect this ratio and therefore have a negative impact on a credit score. Typically if your utilization exceeds 60% of the limit the score will be impacted and exponentially greater impact as the balance approaches the limit.
- 15%: Length of credit history—As a credit history ages it can have a positive impact on its credit score. Conversely, too many newly opened accounts can have a negative impact on the score. Most lenders require at least 3 trade lines with more than 12 months history.
- 10%: Types of credit (Installment, Credit Card or Revolving, Finance Company Lines) Consumers can benefit by having a history of managing different types of credit.
- 10%: Recent Credit Inquiries—Credit “pulls”, which occur when consumers are seeking new credit, can hurt scores. Credit inquiries by individuals shopping for a mortgage or auto loan over a short period (Like kind inquiries over a very short period like a week) have little or no impact, however. While all credit inquiries are recorded and displayed on credit reports for a period of time, credit inquiries that were made by the owner (through online free credit reporting services), or by an employer typically have no impact. Lenders will typically require explanations for all inquiries for the 90 days preceeding an application.
Now lets talk about Cash – Cash is the “Equity Position” in the loan The components of this part of the review include down payment and how much the borrower is putting down relative to the purchase price (known as the LTV or Loan to Value) as well as the source of the funds.
All funds to be used for down payment must be “sourced” meaning the lender must verify the source of all funds in the borrower’s bank accounts. Normally two months’ statements are required and the borrower will be asked to verify the source of all non-payroll deposits. Down payments could be as little as 3.5% for FHA loans or 25% for investment properties. Conforming loans can be done now with 5% down. For FHA loans, the entire down payment can come from a gift by a direct family member. If going this route, the gift must also be sourced and the transfer verified.
In addition to down payment, sufficient funds to cover closing costs and prepaids as well as any reserve requirements must be documented. A good rule of thumb is about 2% of the loan amount, but this is a very rough estimate its best to get a good solid estimate based on the property you are considering and the loan type you are using. In many cases the seller can be asked to cover all or part of the costs. This is typically negotiated up front with the contract.
The other aspect of the “Cash” part of the review is the actual loan to value. This is determined by both the agreed upon sales price and the appraisal done on the home. the lower of the two is used to base the maximum mortgage calculation. Any personal property listed on the contract should be avoided as the appraiser will have to allow for the value of those items and they cannot be included in the value estimate so the loan will be based on sales price (or appraised) less any personal property noted.
A close association with Cash is Collateral in the review. The collateral must support the loan and the home must be demonstrated to be marketable and in average or better condition. As noted above, the Appraised value must support the loan. If the appraisal comes in lower, then the maximum loan would be reduced. The appraisal is a 20-30 page report that reviews the neighborhood, the construction of the home, the marketing time, and uses recent sales of similar homes to determine the relative value of the subject property. Any items of deferred maintenance, or health/safety issues are noted. Any items that do not meet minimum lender requirements (like a bad roof) are noted as “subject to correction” items and must be fixed prior to closing.
Capacity is the borrowers’ ability to repay the loan. This is a comparison of the borrowers income as can be documentated via tax returns, paystubs, and other forms like pension and social security awards letters, 1099′s, etc. Be aware that lenders must use “Adjusted Gross” income meaning that for those that are self employed or in a job where they deduct expenses, its the gross income less any expenses. For self employed, commissioned/bonus or other non-salary positions, an average of the last two years tax returns is required. The NET income from those returns is used as it passes through to the clients’ personal 1040.
This income is compared via two ratios – the Housing Ratio and the Total Debt Ratio. The housing ratio is the total new housing payment (PITIMI – Principal, Interest, Taxes, Insurance, Mortgage Insurance and any condo or homeowners dues if applicable) divided by income. For example if a clients new payment is $1500 and the monthly income is $4000 the debt ratio would be 1500/4000=37.5% Total debt ratio adds in all other debts to the housing payment and divides by income. So $1500 housing + $500 car payment and credit cards / $4000 income = 50%
Maximum debt ratios or “DTI” is typically 45% for conforming loans and 50% for FHA, although some lenders allow for more. If you want to figure out how much of a payment you can qualify for take your gross income (less any deductions as noted above) X either .45 or .50 (if going FHA) and subtract your other debt (excluding rent) The remaining amount is your maximum payment.
For example; if you make $5000 per month and have $600 in car payments and other debt and are going for a FHA loan – 5000X.5=2500 – 600 = $1900 maximum new home payment. Remember that this payment includes all costs associated with the home (the loan payment, mortgage insurance, taxes and insurance and any HOA)
Mortgage Insurance is required on any loan where 20% down is not provided. For conforming loans, the mortgage insurance premium varies based on the percentage down, loan type (fixed or adjustable, 15 year or 30 year) and borrowers credit score. for 10% down, its about .48% (for a $200,000 loan at 10% down this is about $80 per month) For FHA its a bit different. The MIP (mortgage insurance premium) is split with part financed into the loan (1% of the loan amount) and the rest paid monthly at 1.15% of the loan amount / 12 months (200,000 loan @ 1.15%/12 = $191.67 per month.)
Finally the last item is Compensating Factors. No two borrowers needs or situations are the same. Eveyone has a different history, employment or credit situation. In many cases, one or more guidelines as noted above, may not fit exactly within the guidelines of the lender. Therefore a decision to grant credit could be on the fence so to speak. Demonstrating a factor that compensates for the perceived risk helps in these cases. For instance, maybe the DTI is 51% for a FHA loan… but the borrower’s new payment is the same or less than they were paying in rent – demonstrating that they have already proven they can handle a higher DTI. A seasoned and experienced Loan Originator should be able to identify potential risk factors, look for compensating factors and describe them to the underwriter when the loan is submitted for review.
As I noted at the beginning of this very long email, its a great time to buy a home. The best first step is to get preapproved by a qualified and experienced Loan Originator.
Please write with any questions and if we can be of any assistance, please feel free to call us at 954-949-9913
Have a Fabulous Day!